
Getting older has made me slower at almost everything: on the football pitch certainly but also at making decisions, and at getting hot under the collar.
Is there a role for slower thinking in our teams?
Daniel Kahneman in Thinking, Fast and Slow showed how often quick, intuitive judgements lead us astray, and in interviews he advised sleeping on important decisions. So maybe slowing down is a feature of getting older, not a bug.
I was once told that McDonald’s branches with an older employee had happier customers. It turned out to be true. Lancaster University looked at more than 400 UK branches and found customer satisfaction was around 20% higher where staff aged 60 and over were employed. Managers said older workers connected well with customers, and 44% said they mentored younger colleagues.
Picture a lunchtime rush. An order goes wrong, a customer is shouting and the 19-year-old on the till is reacting. The older colleague takes a breath before deciding what to do, and helps everyone else calm down too.
Serving burgers is routine. Calming an angry customer isn’t.
The evidence for generational differences at work, the “Boomers versus Gen Z” kind, is at best mixed (Parry & Urwin, 2011). People born in the same decade differ more from each other than generations do on average.
But most of us do change with age. Studies that follow the same people for decades find we tend to become calmer, more conscientious and more considerate. So expect some shift with age, but don’t assume it, and avoid generational labels. Call someone “a Boomer” and you’ve put them in a box before they’ve opened their mouth. A simple and better approach is just to ask people how they work.
Try this in your next team meeting: ask everyone to answer three questions, then share the answers.
None of the questions mentions age, but the answers show how quickly people like to decide, what “being available” means to them and where their habits come from. Differences in experience can come out without any age stereotyping.
So does every team need an older member? Not necessarily. The research shows that age diversity has the greatest impact where the team faces tough problems. The team also needs to build a culture where diverse voices are heard.
Slow, careful judgement only helps a team that is willing to slow down. Like many other aspects of diversity you can't just throw very different people together and assume it works - you need to invest to create the conditions. Read more over here.
I think AI could make mixed-age teams even more valuable, because it adds a third kind of thinking. AI is fast and has instant recall. Younger colleagues are often keen to explore what’s new. Experienced colleagues tend to know which questions matter, and to slow down when a confident answer feels wrong.
Keeping an age balance helps avoid two pitfalls. If you pair experienced staff with AI and stop hiring the young, you will run out of experienced staff later. This is already happening: Stanford data shows employment of 22–25-year-olds in AI-exposed jobs is about 19% lower than it would otherwise be.
If you pair the young with AI and leave out experience, you may get fast, confident answers that nobody checks. Part of the older colleague’s job is to mentor and ask “How did you get there?” before anyone trusts the AI’s answer. It’s a habit that can be learned.
We’ve already seen a version of this. In Sugata Mitra’s TED Prize-winning “School in the Cloud”, children in India used the internet for answers while a volunteer “granny” on Skype encouraged them, asked “How did you do that?” and admired what they found. Mitra found that this steady encouragement made a real difference to the children.
Age diversity, like any other kind, doesn’t make a team wiser on its own. What helps is the habit of combining different kinds of thinking. As AI takes on more of the fast thinking, the teams that thrive may be the ones that make room for the slow. Try the three questions at your next team meeting and see what comes out.
